Your browser is out of date

This browser version is too old for Quizara to display the page correctly. Update to the latest version and refresh to continue.

Comparing Index Performance

Updated · 2027 Level I · Quantitative Methods · Module 3 · Lesson 5 · 5 min lesson

On this page

What this lesson covers

Index performance reflects each constituent’s return in proportion to its weight; changing the weighting method can change the result even when all constituent returns stay the same.

The lesson decomposes the same four stocks’ index returns into weighted contributions. It compares price-weighted, equal-weighted and market-cap-weighted indexes, then shows how distributions, weight drift, rebalancing and a stock split affect later comparisons.

Key points

  • Contribution: Over a period with no rebalancing, a stock's contribution to an index return is its weight at the start of the period times its own return.
  • Index return: Add up the contributions, and you get the index return.
  • Weighting methods: Over a period with no rebalancing, different weighting methods give different results only because the stocks' returns differ from one another.
  • Reinvested distributions: Over longer periods, the reinvested distributions compound.
  • Weights: Each index reflects the performance of the stocks it weights most heavily, and as prices and market values change, so does their influence.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming index weights stay fixed from year to year overlooks their drift toward stocks whose prices have risen.

How do the results compare?

Scroll horizontally to see every column.

IndexHarbor contribution (pp), +10%Ridge contribution (pp), −20%Peak contribution (pp), 0%Bright contribution (pp), +50%Index return
Price-weighted20% × 10% = +2.060% × (−20%) = −12.016% × 0% = 04% × 50% = +2.0−8%
Equal-weighted, 25% each25% × 10% = +2.525% × (−20%) = −5.025% × 0% = 025% × 50% = +12.5+10%
Market-cap weighted50% × 10% = +5.025% × (−20%) = −5.015% × 0% = 010% × 50% = +5.0+5%

Try a practice question

Choose an answer, then check it to read the explanation for every option.

Practice question

An index holds three stocks with start-of-year weights of 60%, 30% and 10%, and with no rebalancing during the year the stocks return -5%, 20% and 6%. The index's return for the year is closest to:

Continue studying in Quizara

In Quizara the lesson comes with more practice questions on the topic, explanations for every option and an AI tutor for your follow-up questions.

Written by the Quizara Editorial Team under our editorial standards.